循证拆解 · 9 篇文献支撑Evidence-based teardown · 9 sources

生命不是家谱 A LIFEIS NOTA PEDIGREE

—— 证书查不到的,才最重要 ↘ — What the certificate can't verify matters most ↘

血统可以证明一只动物从哪里来,却不能证明它会健康、温顺,也不能证明它适合你。当「纯种」「冠军后代」「赛级血线」被包装成品质指标,你买到的往往不是更可靠的伙伴,而是一套更昂贵的营销叙事 A pedigree proves where an animal came from — not whether it will be healthy, gentle, or right for you. When "purebred", "champion-sired" and "show-line" are packaged as markers of quality, what you're buying is often not a more reliable companion, but a more expensive marketing story.

5 组迷思5 myths 4 组硬数据4 hard datasets 9 面红旗9 red flags 12 项清单12 checks
INTERNATIONAL PET REGISTRY · 国际宠物登记处INTERNATIONAL PET REGISTRY

纯种血统证书Pedigree Certificate

OFFICIAL PEDIGREE CERTIFICATE · NO. 089-2461
登记品种Registered breed英国短毛猫British Shorthair
血系Lineage冠军血线(隔三代)"Champion line" (3 gen. back)
毛色Color蓝灰 · 稀有色Blue-gray · "rare"
近交系数 COIInbreeding (COI)未检测NOT TESTED
父母健康筛查Parental screening未提供NOT PROVIDED
性格 / 社会化评估Temperament无记录NO RECORDS
本证书仅证明登记信息,不构成对健康、性格或家庭适配性的任何担保。 This certificate attests to registration only. It is no guarantee of health, temperament, or fit with your family.
它从哪里来 ✓ Where it came from ✓ 会不会生病?✗ Will it get sick? ✗ 适不适合你?✗ Right for you? ✗ 这些它都不写 None of that is written here
证据不足NO PROOF
SCROLL · 往下拆SCROLL · TEAR IT DOWN
01 / 迷思01 / MYTHS

五句被故意混淆的话

Five deliberately blurred lines

商业宣传把「血统」和「品质」捆在一起卖。下面每一句,都是经不起推敲的概念偷换——红线划掉的不是血统本身,而是这套逻辑。 Commercial marketing welds "pedigree" to "quality". Every line below is a bait-and-switch that won't survive scrutiny — the red line strikes the logic, not the pedigree itself.

有血统 = 身体更好Pedigree = better health

封闭基因库 + 近交系数攀升,反而可能放大隐性遗传病风险,带来繁殖力与幼仔存活率下降的「近交衰退」。Closed gene pools and rising inbreeding can amplify recessive disease risk — inbreeding depression hits fertility, pup survival, and overall fitness.

祖先得过奖 = 后代一定优秀Award-winning ancestor = guaranteed great offspring

遗传组合是随机的。祖先的奖杯不会自动变成后代的好脾气,更不会替你完成社会化和训练。Genetic recombination is random. A trophy on the wall doesn't hand down a good temperament — and it won't do the socializing or training for you.

外形符合标准 = 品质更高Conforming to the standard = higher quality

有些「标准」本身就是病:扁脸、折耳、短腿、暴眼——越标准,越痛苦Some "standards" are diseases by design: flat faces, folded ears, short legs, bulging eyes — the more "standard", the more suffering.

品种稀有 = 更有价值Rare breed = more valuable

稀缺可以被人为制造。稀有色、罕见花纹,常常只是定价策略,不是品质认证。Scarcity can be manufactured. "Rare colors" and "unusual patterns" are usually pricing strategy, not proof of quality.

售价昂贵 = 更值得珍惜High price = more worth cherishing

高价只能证明卖方成功建立了价格,不能证明繁育过程科学。A high price only proves the seller successfully set a price — not that the breeding behind it was sound.

02 / 证书02 / THE CERT

一张证书,只回答三个问题

One certificate, three questions answered

血统证书不是健康证明,不是性格报告,也不是适配性担保。它的能力边界,比销售话术里小得多。 A pedigree is not a health report, a temperament assessment, or a compatibility guarantee. Its actual scope is far smaller than the sales pitch implies.

它能证明WHAT IT PROVES

登记在册的三件事Three things on the register

  • 它被登记为什么品种What breed it's registered as
  • 它的父母是谁Who its parents are
  • 它的祖先是否进入某个登记体系Whether its ancestors entered a registry
它不能证明WHAT IT DOESN'T

你真正关心的四件事The four things you actually care about

  • 它有没有遗传病Whether it carries genetic disease
  • 繁育过程是否科学Whether the breeding was done soundly
  • 幼年期是否得到良好照顾Whether it was raised well as a youngster
  • 成年后是否适合你的家庭Whether it will fit your family as an adult

把生命简化成一张家谱,本身就是对复杂现实的误判。只展示血统证书、却回避父母健康筛查的卖家,是一个非常明显的警讯 Reducing a life to a family tree is a misreading of a complex reality. A seller who flashes the pedigree but dodges parental health screening is waving a very obvious warning flag.

03 / 数据03 / THE DATA

把数字摆上桌

Put the numbers on the table

「纯种必然更健康」和「混种天然没病」是两句同样草率的口号。证据站在中间:风险取决于具体疾病、具体品种、具体家系和具体繁育方式。 "Purebreds are always healthier" and "mixed breeds never get sick" are equally sloppy slogans. The evidence sits in the middle: risk depends on the specific disease, breed, family line, and breeding practice.

0%

亲兄妹交配后代的理论近交系数(COI)。近交程度持续上升,会让隐性有害变异成对出现的机会变大。Theoretical inbreeding coefficient (COI) of a full-sibling mating. As inbreeding climbs, harmful recessive variants are increasingly likely to pair up.

群体遗传学常识POPULATION GENETICS 101
0%

犬类个体行为差异中,「品种」平均只能解释的比例。研究告诉我们:看到品种就预测个体性格,超出了证据能支持的范围。The share of individual behavioral differences in dogs that "breed" explains on average. research says: predicting an individual's personality from its breed outruns the evidence.

SCIENCE · 2022 · 2000+ 犬基因数据2,000+ DOGS GENOTYPED [4]
0

UC Davis 兽医教学医院研究中,携带至少一种遗传性疾病的犬只样本量,覆盖 24 种疾病的纯种 / 混种比较。Dogs with at least one inherited disorder in the UC Davis veterinary teaching-hospital study, covering 24 conditions compared across purebreds and mixed breeds.

JAVMA · 2013 [2]
0

纯种更高发

more common in purebreds

0

无显著差异

no significant difference

0

混种更高发*

more common in mixed*

*前十字韧带断裂。24 种疾病里,13 种在纯种与混种之间没有显著差异。*Cranial cruciate ligament rupture. Of 24 conditions, 13 showed no significant difference between purebreds and mixed breeds.

24 种疾病比较24 CONDITIONS COMPARED [2]

」:
账面上很多,基因里很少
The "":
many on paper, few in the gene pool

品种登记册一旦封闭,新的遗传变异就很难进入。若繁育者反复使用少数种公种母,登记数量再庞大,真正向下一代贡献大量基因的也只有顶端那几个个体——对英国犬业俱乐部十个品种家谱的研究发现,多数受研究品种的很低。[1]Once a breed's registry closes, new genetic variation can barely enter. When a handful of sires and dams are used over and over, it doesn't matter how big the registered population looks — only the individuals at the top actually contribute genes. A pedigree study of ten UK Kennel Club breeds found most had very low . [1]

纸面家谱上看似关系不近的两只动物,基因组层面的相似度仍可能很高。所以,登记数量庞大 ≠ 遗传多样性充足Two dogs that look distantly related on paper can still be highly similar at the genomic level. So: a large registered population ≠ sufficient genetic diversity.

热门种公 ASIRE A 热门种公 BSIRE B 热门种公 CSIRE C 登记在册的庞大种群 —— 每一根线,都是一次基因贡献 The vast registered population — every line is a genetic contribution
04 / 实验室04 / THE LAB

近交系数体验台

The inbreeding coefficient bench

衡量的是概率,不是判决书。点选一种配种关系,看看后代理论上的遗传起点在哪里。 The measures probabilities, not verdicts. Pick a mating type and see where the offspring theoretically starts.

0% 15% 30%
— —理论 COITHEORETICAL COI

注意:COI 是群体统计量,不能断定某只个体一定生病;家谱 COI 受记录代数与准确性限制,基因组 COI 依据 DNA 纯合片段估计,两者可能不一致。此外,的存在意味着:低 COI 是必要条件,不是健康通行证。 Note: COI is a population statistic; it can't decree that a given individual will fall ill. Pedigree COI is limited by the depth and accuracy of records; genomic COI, estimated from runs of homozygosity in DNA, may tell a different story. And because and exist, a low COI is a necessary condition — not a health passport.

05 / 话术05 / THE SPIN

话术
翻译机

The spin
translator

销售页上的高频词,逐条翻译成人话。点击任意一条,看它原本的意思。 The buzzwords of every listing page, translated into plain language. Click any line to see what it actually means.

付款之前,先翻译一遍 → Translate before you pay →
家谱里隔了好几代的某位亲戚,曾经在某个规则下赢过一场比赛。你付的是冠军溢价,得到的是一个遥远的亲缘故事——比赛成绩和「适合你家」之间,隔着遗传随机性、个体差异和成长环境。A relative several generations back once won a show under a particular set of rules.You paid a champion premium for a distant family anecdote — between a show record and "right for your home" lie genetic randomness, individual differences, and upbringing.
「未检出已检测的变异」只对被检测的那几个位点负责。要继续追问:测的是哪些变异?机构与样本身份能否核验?髋肘影像、眼科、心脏超声这些 DNA 测不出的筛查做了吗?"Cleared of the variants tested" only covers the exact loci tested.Keep asking: which variants? Can the lab and sample identity be verified? Were the screenings DNA can't do — hip/elbow imaging, eye exams, cardiac ultrasound — actually performed?
「我们家从没出过问题」也一样——这是承诺,不是证据。证据是可核验的筛查报告:按品种风险组合的检测、影像评估、正规体检记录,以及繁育双方完整的健康资料。"We've never had a problem" too — that's a promise, not evidence.Evidence is verifiable screening records: breed-appropriate panels, imaging, proper vet exams, and complete health documentation on both parents.
稀缺感是可以被制造的营销原料。售价高只能证明卖方成功建立了价格。稀有 ≠ 更好,贵 ≠ 更负责。Scarcity is a marketing ingredient that can be manufactured.A high price only proves the seller successfully set a price. Rare ≠ better. Expensive ≠ responsible.
这句话同样是口号。杂交可能降低部分隐性风险、产生,但若亲本共享同一风险变异、或疾病本身是多基因性的,混种后代照样可能患病。风险取决于具体疾病、具体家系、具体繁育方式——健康必须用证据判断,不能从「纯不纯」直接推导。Also a slogan. Outcrossing can dilute some recessive risks and produce , but if both parents share the same risk variant, or the disease is polygenic, mixed-breed offspring can still be affected.Risk depends on the specific disease, the specific line, the specific breeding practice — health must be judged by evidence, never derived from "pure or not".
催你付款的紧迫感,是成交技巧,不是动物的需求。一个真正负责任的繁育者会筛选买家、关心动物去向——而不是谁付款就卖给谁。The urgency pushing you to pay is a closing technique, not the animal's need.A truly responsible breeder screens buyers and cares where the animal goes — not whoever pays first.
06 / 红旗06 / RED FLAGS

卖家红旗扫描仪

The seller red-flag scanner

把下面九条当成 X 光片,对着你正在聊的那个卖家照一遍。点选即判定,无需提交。 Hold these nine items up to the seller you're talking to, like an X-ray. Tap to score — nothing is submitted.

0

面红旗已触发

RED FLAGS RAISED

宁可错查,不可漏查 ↑ Better to over-check than miss one ↑
07 / 代价07 / THE COST

当「萌」是疾病的包装

When "cute" is the packaging for disease

有些外形在照片里很可爱,在现实里是终身医疗。把疾病相关特征浪漫化,是最需要警惕的事。 Some looks are adorable in photos and a lifetime of treatment in reality. Romancing disease-linked traits is what deserves the most alarm.

睡觉打呼好可爱The snoring is so cute:狭窄鼻孔、过长软腭,呼吸是在用力挣命: narrowed nostrils and an overlong soft palate — every breath is labor
安静省心So calm and low-maintenance运动不耐受、发绀、晕厥、高温下散热困难Exercise intolerance, cyanosis, fainting, inability to cool down in heat
走路一扭一扭很萌That waddle is adorable软骨发育异常、进行性退行性关节病Cartilage dysplasia, progressive degenerative joint disease
娇贵"Delicate"终身依赖医疗干预A lifetime dependent on medical intervention
这是品种的 normal 代价That's just the breed's "normal cost"无法自然分娩、眼球突出易角膜损伤——被说成「正常」的痛苦Inability to birth naturally, protruding eyes prone to corneal injury — suffering rebranded as "normal"
典型案例 NO.1CASE FILE NO.1

短吻犬 · 被选育出来的呼吸困难Brachycephalic dogs — breathing difficulty, bred on purpose

短头犬阻塞性气道综合征(BOAS)是「外形—功能—福利」联系的典型:狭窄鼻孔、过长增厚的软腭、拥挤的鼻腔结构增加上气道阻力,长期用力吸气又引起继发性改变,形成恶性循环。流行病学与全身体积描记研究已验证面部构型与气道阻塞风险的关联。Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS) is the textbook case of "form–function–welfare": narrowed nostrils, an overlong thickened soft palate, and crowded nasal passages raise airway resistance; the chronic effort of breathing then triggers secondary changes — a vicious cycle. Epidemiology and whole-body plethysmography have confirmed the link between facial conformation and airway obstruction.

O'NEILL 2015 · LIU 2016 [6][7]
典型案例 NO.2CASE FILE NO.2

苏格兰折耳猫 · 折耳就是症状本身Scottish Folds — the fold IS the symptom

折耳表型与 TRPV4 基因的显性变异相关:一份变异拷贝就足以影响软骨发育,可能出现四肢、尾部畸形及进行性关节病。折耳不是装饰性耳形,而是同一软骨发育变异的可见标志。The folded ear is tied to a dominant variant in the TRPV4 gene: a single copy is enough to disrupt cartilage development, potentially causing limb and tail deformities and progressive joint disease. The fold is not a decorative ear shape — it's the visible sign of that same cartilage variant.

GANDOLFI 2016 · RORDEN 2021 [8][9]

喜欢,不能自动使伤害合理化。
付得起医疗费,也不等于有权主动制造可预见的痛苦。
Affection does not automatically justify harm.
Being able to afford the vet bills doesn't mean you have the right to manufacture foreseeable suffering.

如果一种外形越「标准」,动物越难正常呼吸、行走、散热或繁殖——需要被重新审视的就不只是繁育技术,也包括我们的消费审美。 When a more "standard" look means the animal breathes, walks, cools itself, or reproduces with more difficulty — what needs re-examining is not just breeding technique, but our consumer aesthetics.

08 / 风险速查08 / RISK INDEX

这些名字背后的隐藏账单

The hidden bill behind these names

喜欢某个品种不是罪,但要知道它为这个外形付着什么账。按物种筛选,看看高发风险和你该追问什么。 Liking a breed is no sin — but know what it pays for that look. Filter by species; see the prevalent risks and the questions to ask.

DOG

法国斗牛犬 · 巴哥 · 英斗French Bulldog · Pug · English Bulldog

短头犬阻塞性气道综合征(BOAS)Brachycephalic Obstructive Airway Syndrome (BOAS)

狭窄鼻孔、过长软腭让呼吸终身费力,还常伴脊柱与眼部问题。Narrowed nostrils and an overlong soft palate make breathing lifelong labor; spinal and eye problems often tag along.

该问:父母安静状态下的呼吸视频?做过 BOAS 分级评估吗?[6][7]Ask: calm-state breathing video of the parents? Any BOAS grading? [6][7]

CAT

苏格兰折耳猫Scottish Fold

TRPV4 显性变异 · 骨软骨发育不良TRPV4 dominant variant · osteochondrodysplasia

折耳本身就是软骨发育变异的可见标志,可能伴四肢、尾部畸形与进行性关节病。The folded ear itself is the visible sign of a cartilage variant; limb and tail deformities and progressive joint disease can follow.

该问:双亲耳形?做过四肢与尾部影像检查吗?[8][9]Ask: both parents' ear shape? Imaging of limbs and tail? [8][9]

DOG

金毛 · 拉布拉多 · 德牧Golden · Labrador · German Shepherd

髋 / 肘关节发育不良Hip / elbow dysplasia

多基因性状,DNA 测不出来,必须依靠影像学评估。Polygenic; DNA can't rule it out — only imaging can.

该问:父母有无 OFA / PennHIP 髋肘评分?[3]Ask: OFA / PennHIP hip and elbow scores for the parents? [3]

DOG

骑士查理王小猎犬Cavalier King Charles Spaniel

二尖瓣疾病(MVD)Mitral valve disease (MVD)

该品种心脏病高发,严重个体中年即可能出现心衰。The breed is highly prone to heart disease; severe individuals can reach heart failure in middle age.

该问:父母心脏超声报告?听诊记录?Ask: parents' echocardiogram reports? Auscultation records?

CAT

波斯猫 · 异国短毛猫Persian · Exotic Shorthair

多囊肾(PKD)+ 短吻问题Polycystic kidney disease (PKD) + brachycephalic issues

单基因病,可 DNA 检测;扁脸又叠加呼吸风险。A single-gene disease, DNA-testable; the flat face stacks breathing risk on top.

该问:父母 PKD 检测报告?静息呼吸是否顺畅?Ask: parents' PKD test results? Resting breathing smooth?

DOG

腊肠犬 · 柯基Dachshund · Corgi

椎间盘疾病Intervertebral disc disease

软骨发育异常体型让脊柱终身承压,瘫痪风险显著。The chondrodystrophic build loads the spine for life; paralysis risk is significant.

该问:父母有无脊椎影像?家族有无瘫痪病史?Ask: spinal imaging of parents? Family history of paralysis?

CAT

缅因猫 · 布偶猫Maine Coon · Ragdoll

肥厚型心肌病(HCM)Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM)

大型猫种高发的心脏病,是幼猫猝死风险之一。Common in large cat breeds; one of the causes of sudden death in young cats.

该问:父母心脏超声?是否携带 HCM 相关变异?Ask: parents' echocardiogram? HCM-related variant status?

DOG

边境牧羊犬Border Collie

柯利眼异常(CEA)· 癫痫Collie eye anomaly (CEA) · epilepsy

工作犬光环之下,同样有品种高发的遗传病。Under the working-dog halo, the same breed-typical inherited diseases.

该问:CEA / TNS 等品种组合检测做了哪些?Ask: which breed panels — CEA / TNS and the like — were run?

09 / 该看什么09 / WHAT TO LOOK AT

五件真正该看的事

The five things actually worth looking at

与其追问祖上拿过多少奖,不如把目光移到眼前这个具体的生命,和它背后具体的繁育方式上。 Rather than asking how many prizes the ancestors won, turn your eyes to this specific animal in front of you — and the specific breeding practice behind it.

01

看自己,而不是先看宠物Look at yourself first, not the pet

每天能投入多少时间?能否接受掉毛、叫声、拆家?住所稳定吗?家人同意吗?能否承担常规医疗和突发治疗?未来十多年搬家、结婚、生育、换城市,它怎么办?How much time can you give every day? Can you live with shedding, barking, destroyed furniture? Is your housing stable? Is your family on board? Can you cover routine care and emergency treatment? Through moves, marriage, children, new cities over the next fifteen years — what happens to it?

很多不幸不是因为宠物血统不好,而是人从未认真评估自己是否适合饲养Many sad endings aren't because the pet's pedigree was bad, but because the person never honestly assessed whether they were fit to keep one.

02

看健康证据,而不是健康承诺Look at health evidence, not health promises

根据品种风险查对应检测,核对报告主体、机构、日期与结果,必要时咨询独立兽医。警惕三种偷换概念:把「携带者」说成「已患病」;把「未检出某个变异」说成「绝无遗传病」;把「完成检查」说成「结果正常」。Check the screenings that match the breed's risks; verify the report's subject, lab, date, and results; consult an independent vet if needed. Watch for three bait-and-switches: "carrier" recast as "affected"; "clear of this variant" recast as "free of genetic disease"; "examined" recast as "results were normal".

OFA 的 CHIC 项目思路是按品种风险组合多种筛查,而不是把一张 DNA 报告当万能通行证。[3]The OFA's CHIC program embodies the right idea: a panel of screenings matched to breed risk — not one DNA report as an all-access pass. [3]

03

看性格和需求,而不是幼年外形Look at temperament and needs, not the baby face

毛色会变、体型会变、幼态会消失,但运动需求、训练成本和行为问题会长期存在。观察眼前这个个体:它如何回应陌生人?面对声音和新环境能否恢复平静?是否愿意互动?有没有明显恐惧、攻击或刻板行为?Coat color changes, size changes, the baby fluff fades — but exercise needs, training costs, and behavior problems persist. Observe this individual: how does it respond to strangers? Can it settle after a noise or a new place? Does it want to interact? Any obvious fear, aggression, or stereotypies?

这些信息通常比宣传册上的头衔更接近未来的真实生活This information usually predicts your real future far better than the titles on the brochure.

04

看成长环境,而不是精修照片Look at the rearing environment, not the retouched photos

要求查看真实饲养场所、母体状态和幼宠互动方式。长期笼养、环境脏乱、同场动物过多、拒绝展示母体、幼宠精神状态异常——任何一条都该让你停下来。Ask to see the actual premises, the dam's condition, and how the young animals are handled. Long-term caging, filth, overcrowding, refusal to show the dam, listless youngsters — any one of these should stop you.

即使家谱漂亮,出生在拥挤、嘈杂、缺少互动的繁殖场,早期行为发展依然会受影响。[5]Even a beautiful pedigree can't undo a start in a crowded, noisy, interaction-starved breeding mill — early behavioral development will still be shaped by it. [5]

05

看它如何处理「卖不掉」和「养不了」Look at how they handle "unsold" and "can't keep"

幼宠生病、出现遗传问题、买家将来无法继续饲养——对方会怎么处理?负责任的来源不会把交付当成责任的终点,会在合同里写清遗传病责任,并承诺协助接回或安置。If the animal falls ill, shows a genetic problem, or the buyer can no longer keep it — what happens? A responsible source doesn't treat handover as the end of responsibility: genetic-disease liability goes in the contract, and they promise to take the animal back or help rehome it.

回答是否具体,往往比血统故事更能体现底线How concretely they answer says more about their bottom line than any pedigree story.

10 / 测验10 / THE QUIZ

血统迷信指数测试

The pedigree-myth susceptibility test

六句话,判断对错。测测营销叙事在你身上还剩多少效力。 Six statements. True or false. Measure how much of the marketing narrative still works on you.

11 / 最后一关11 / FINAL GATE

带它回家之前

Before you bring it home

12 个问题,逐条打勾。这不是道德考试,是风险排查——勾不出来,就是答案。 Twelve questions, checked one by one. This isn't a morality exam — it's a risk audit. If you can't check them, that's your answer.

购买前必填FILL BEFORE PAYING
确认进度 CONFIRMED
0 / 12

勾选会自动保存在本机浏览器,下次打开仍在。Your checks are saved in this browser and will be here next time.

购买还是领养,都不是道德捷径Neither buying nor adopting is a moral shortcut

领养值得鼓励,但它不是一句口号——部分救助动物有未知病史、行为创伤或特殊照护需求,同样需要专业评估、耐心磨合和长期投入。购买也不必被一概污名化,重视健康与福利的负责任繁育者,与宠物工厂有本质区别。原则只有一条:不论通过哪种方式获得宠物,都不应支持虐待、过度繁殖、隐瞒疾病和冲动消费。Adoption deserves encouragement, but it isn't a slogan — many rescued animals carry unknown histories, trauma, or special care needs, and need professional assessment, patience, and long-term investment. Buying needn't be universally stigmatized either: a breeder who prioritizes health and welfare is a different species from a puppy mill. Only one principle holds: however you acquire a pet, never support cruelty, overbreeding, concealed disease, or impulse buying.

选择宠物的本质,不是挑选一件血统最漂亮的商品,而是判断自己能否接住一个真实、复杂、会生病、会衰老、也会依赖你一生的生命

Choosing a pet is not about picking the product with the prettiest pedigree — it's about judging whether you can hold a real, complicated life that will get sick, will grow old, and will depend on you for all of it.

一个成熟的饲养者,不会把「纯不纯」放在「健康不健康」之前,不会把「稀不稀有」放在「是否痛苦」之前,也不会把「值多少钱」放在「是否值得善待」之前。 A mature keeper never puts "pure or not" before "healthy or not", "rare or not" before "suffering or not", or "what it's worth" before "whether it deserves care".